Bolivia / Procedimientos conocidos
Auto Supremo 177/2024
Procedimientos conocidos. La inclusión en esta ficha no convierte una referencia extranjera en una decisión nacional. Se conserva el estado y el alcance de la fuente.
Expediente y fuentes
- Nombre
- Auto Supremo 177/2024
- Cita
- O-4-21-S
- Tribunal
- Tribunal Supremo de Justicia, Sala Civil
- Instancia
- última instancia
- Fechas
- Decisión
- 2024-03-12
- Estado
- resuelto-firmeza-no-verificada
- Resultado
- ANULA; new appellate ruling ordered; no merits remedy.
- Resumen
- The TSJ found external incongruence (citra petita), annulled Auto de Vista 239/2020 back to the draw, and ordered a new appellate merits ruling without addressing the substantive copyright/sign claims.
- Antecedentes
- The same Oruro musical-association dispute later decided in Auto Supremo 810/2024 reached the TSJ after Auto de Vista 239/2020 confirmed the 2020 trial judgment.
- Historia procesal
- On the first cassation, Auto Supremo 177/2024 reviewed whether the appellate court had answered the material grievances. It did not reach the copyright/sign merits and remanded for a new appellate ruling, which became Auto de Vista 181/2024 and led to Auto Supremo 810/2024.
- Cuestión jurídica
- Whether Auto de Vista 239/2020 omitted material appellate grievances.
- Criterio
- The TSJ found external incongruence (citra petita), annulled Auto de Vista 239/2020 back to the draw, and ordered a new appellate merits ruling without addressing the substantive copyright/sign claims.
- Fundamento decisivo
- A second-instance court must answer the material appellate grievances; omission creates external incongruence requiring annulment rather than a merits ruling by the cassation court.
- Límites
- This is a procedural ruling in the Unión Pagador chain. It does not establish authorship, originality, infringement, registration effect or a GenAI rule.
- Relevancia
- doctrina-general
- Referencias relacionadas
- BOL/as-810-2024
- BOL/tjca-97-ip-2021
- Peso del precedente
- National apex procedural authority, linked to but not counted as a separate merits criterion. Integración/votación: Relator José Antonio Revilla Martínez; complete panel/vote tally not published in retained mirror.
- Fuente
- Referencia
- Auto Supremo 177/2024
- Enlace
- Consultar fuente
- Autoridad
- Tribunal Supremo de Justicia, Sala Civil
- Tipo
- full-text mirror of official source
- Tipo de evidencia
- full-text mirror of official source
- Localizador
- Considerando IV and POR TANTO; source identifies official Génesis record 84479
- Verificación documentada
- Sí